Guest Post: President Barack Obama Twitter Townhall

2011.07.07

Starting two hours before the Twitter Town Hall with President Barack Obama I followed the #AskObama trends on Twitter to see the type of questions they would be asking. There were various types of questions, some hostile, others serious, and more or less comical ones. It seems like of the tweets that were posted are a reflection of the current political climate.

I’d say 20% were  substantive:
@brucelesley: Child poverty in the U.S. is approaching 25%. What is our nation doing to address this national crisis? #AskObama

20% were slanderous and inflammatory:
Example:
@southsalem: Who gave you the Mao Xmas ornament: Marshall Davis, Bill Ayers, Reverend Wright, Tony Rezko, Rashid Khalidi, VanJones? #AskObama
and
@anabeavenhauser: WWMD….What would Mohammad do? #askobama.

Although these comments did add a hostile feel to the monitoring of the incoming tweets they did not loom over the finished product of the actual Town Hall, and there were some substantive questions.

60% were somewhere in-between, and relatively harmless (if not funny ;-) )
@drbrown_bear: Mac or PC??? #AskObama.

@Kaore: Will you insist the Dems NOT cave to GOP hostage taking? Why do we CONSTANTLY insist on bipartisanship when they don’t want it? #askobama

Only seventeen out of what I can only assume were hundreds of thousand of questions were answered live on with Twitter founder, Jack Dorsey as moderator. My Tweetdeck was very chaotic and once the Q&A began I had to turn it off because questions were flying so quickly that it was impossible to read them fast enough. Truly, overwhelming.

I thought President Obama gave detailed, thoughtful answers to all of the questions he was asked, and overall I feel that it was a very powerful and insightful Town Hall. At this moment there are still questions flying on the #AskObama hashtag. It was an example of the all inclusiveness mentioned in previous posts (See Phil Ting Interview) that makes government transparency efficient and important. As Tweeter, jeremyt1982 said, “I think this #AskObama stream is really going to take off…”

The questions selected are listed below (as re-tweeted by @TownHall)

To watch the replay of the Obama Town Hall click here

@ModeledBehavior Modeled Behavior
So will you raise taxes on the middle class at least to W Bush levels@askObama @townhall

pedsnursemarcia marcia schneider

@AssignmentDesk1 #AskObama Public Edu here in CA falling apart. Not grad enough skilled workers or smart citizens. Privitization looming?

flynnbw Brendan W. Flynn

@WhiteHouse We definitely need to get more vets into jobs. But when are we going to support the troops by cutting oil dependence? #AskObama

Shnaps Shnaps

Is free-market an option? RT @whitehouse: Obama on homeowners underwater: Have made some progress, but+ needed, looking at options #askObama

almorrison88 Lane Morrison

#askobama What changes to the tax system do you think are necessary to help solve the deficit problem and for the system to be fair?

NickKristof Nicholas Kristof

#AskObama Was it a mistake to fail to get Republicans to commit to raise the debt ceiling, at the same time tax cuts were extended?

craigoc34 Craigoc

@whitehouse @townhall My question is can you give companies a tax break if they hire a Honorable discharged Veteran?

nealhannon Neal Hannon

Small biz create jobs. What incentives are you willing to support to improve small biz growth? #AskObama

johnboehner John Boehner

After embarking on a record spending binge that’s left us deeper in debt, where are the jobs? #AskObama

robinmarty robinmarty

@Kara_McGuire How will admin work to help underwater homeowners who aren’t behind in payments but are trapped in homes they can’t sell?

pmglynn Patrick Glynn

Mr. President, In several states we have seen people lose their collective bargaining rights. Do you have a plan to rectify this? #AskObama

awg9988 Allison Good

@KimQuillenTP Will you focus on promoting alternative energy industries in oil states like Louisiana and Texas? #townhall

ensina Sina

Immigrant entrepreneurs can build companies and create jobs for US workers. Will you support a startup visa program? #askobama

_RenegadeNerd_ Dexter Smith
#AskObama Mr. President, will you issue an executive order to raise the debt ceiling pursuant to section 4 of the 14th amendment?

dwhite105 Dustin White

Higher ed. is necessary for a stronger economy, but for some middle class Americans it’s becoming too expensive. What can be done? #askobama

dmscott David Meerman Scott

#AskObama Tech & knowledge industries are thriving, yet jobs discussion always centers on manufacturing. Why not be realistic about jobs?

conblog William Smith
@DrewHampshire: What mistakes have you made in handling this recession and what would you do differently? #askObama

(Photo by: http://blog.twitter.com/2011/07/twitter-town-hall.html)

Post by Mallory Garrett, BYO (http://byoconsulting.com) Summer Intern

Interview with Phil Ting: Openness in Elections and Government

2011.07.02

While in San Fransisco last month I had the pleasure of interviewing San Fransisco Mayoral Candidate and Harvard Kennedy School alum Phil Ting. We talked all things gov20, and had a fascinating conversation about his campaign, life working in SF government, and his thoughts around what public policy students need to learn to be leaders in a networked world.

Phil Ting is running a transparent campaign, and is focusing his efforts on engaging San Franciscans through Reset San Francisco, an online forum designed to give people opportunities to interact with each other and their elected officials to discuss the issues they care about. Ting is a gov20 advocate, and understands the challenges and opportunities of large-scale engagement:

“the way we [the government] get feedback is so archaic and has such an inability to process large amounts of information that you can only get feedback from five or ten people…and the other ten thousand people…are shut out of the process. So how do you really open it up to be representative…you have to go get enough people so that you are getting a response that is accurate to the population…I think that is what we are trying to do with Reset San Francisco, is not just get feed back but then say, ‘hey, I can’t do it by myself, I’m just one person … we need people’s help to do it.”

Here is a summary of our conversation (Listen to the full interview here):

1. What are your priorities for this campaign?
Our main priority for this campaign is to change the way the people elect the mayor of San Francisco. Traditionally, politicians cater to interest groups to leverage their power. However, this shuts out the rest of the population.  We want to win this election by empowering individuals and increasing the number of active participants in the campaign from a few hundred to thousands. Our campaign seeks to skip the game playing and go right to the people. By fostering an exchange of  ideas we are helping them become more involved and engaged to make government more transparent and accessible. This is how the idea of Reset San Francisco came about.

2. So what is Reset San Fransisco all about? What is the User Experience like on the platform?
The participant gets a login, picture, and has the option to link it to their Facebook. Members can then go in and read or comment and be a part of the dialogue. In their profile, they can give their name or be anonymous and provide as little or as much information as they wish. This is a safe space to talk about the issues San Franciscans care about.

San Franciscans are able to be a part of the political process and learn about their government, community, and get involved through the following features:
  • Participate in online discussions through message boards and chat rooms

  • Give feedback through surveys and polls

  • Interact with elected officials and neighbors through Offline Community Events

  • Open a profile that has their picture, information, and other information they wish to disclose.

  • Access content in Chinese, Russian, Spanish, Vietnamese, and English.

  • Link to facebook
  • Obtain information about events, processes, and need-to-know resident information.

3. How do you translate the principles of engagement in your campaign into structures of governance?

Working with the barriers to, not avoid them, but change them and adapt the system to work for the people. I serve as both the head of a governmental department as well as a mayoral candidate. Therefore, I implement change within my division to better serve the community. This is how something is taken from a campaign promise to policy.

4. What challenges do you face in using technology to engage?
In tough financial times, people perceive technology as a luxury rather than part of their core business model. People are also overworked; therefore, the idea of opening something up as more work not less work is a hindrance. There are also people in government who are looking to keep things the same and they don’t like change. Although the Internet eliminates the hindrances of time and location, many people perceive it as promoting less interaction rather then more.

5. What are some interesting things that have come out of Reset San Francisco?
The petitions are extremely successful. We have a solar program in San Fransisco that actually brings in more money than it costs. However, there was a government proposal to cut funding for this program. The Go Solar SF petition was started on Reset SF and received over 700 signatures that led to a rally being held with city workers and environmentalists who demanded that the program be saved. This highlights the power of using online organizing to spur offline behavior.

6. One of the things we thought about a lot at the Kennedy School was the extent of technology training needed for Public Policy students, aspiring to careers in public service. You are a Kennedy School alum and dedicated public servant and are committed to using tech in your work; what do you think HKS students should learn regarding technology?
How to communicate with the public is a vital part of using technology to expand engagement. Communication is not just about giving a speech, but how feedback is processed and used to improve the organization. Good organizations who want to become great take feedback and use it to make things work more effectively.

San Francisco will hold its mayoral election on Tuesday November 8, 2011. Currently, Edwin M. Lee is holding the office of Mayor as a replacement for Gavin Newsom who is now serving as Lieutenant Governor of California (elected 2010). For more information on each candidates open government platform, check out Code for America’s recap on the SFOpen 2011 debate. The current candidates are:

Name Current Position Political Affiliation
Michela Alioto-Pier San Francisco Board of Supervisors Democrat
John Avalos San Francisco Board of Supervisors Democrat
David Chiu San Francisco Board of Supervisors Democrat
Bevan Dufty San Francisco Board of Supervisors Democrat
Tony Hall San Francisco Board of Supervisors
Dennis Herrera San Francisco City Attorney Democrat
Joanna Rees Venture Capitalist Progressive Independent
Phil Ting San Francisco Assessor-Recorder Democrat
Leland Yee California State Senator Democrat